David Warlick on the Profile 3

Profiles have great potential, writes David Warlick:

I’ve mentioned this in some of my presentations, that I do not believe that we – educators older than 30 (arbitrarily chosen age) – truly understand social networks yet.  For instance, we’re trying to grow individual and independent social networks out of every discipline, school level, and just about any other probable community of educational interest.  I’ll bet I’ve been contaced by e-mail or phone call by no fewer than ten people over the past month, each wanting me to see their social network.  “This social network is going to revolutionize physical education!”

What strikes me is that our students make it work with just one.  The three main choices, as far as I know, are MySpace, Bebo, and Facebook, the later seeming to be the one of choice at present.  So why didn’t we figure out how to use Facebook as the social network for NECC.  I looked there for a group for NECC.  I probably won’t do that again :-/

So, anyway, I keep wondering about this.  What’s the point, beyond costing time, which I guess many of our students have more to spend.  It seems to me, that the true potential for all of this, and something that I don’t even think Facebook has truly captured yet, is the profile.  What bothers me about social networks is that they have walls.  It’s a weekness of Ning, in my opinion, that there do not seem to be easy and logical ways for us to connect to each other, based on common interests, regardless of the networks we’ve joined.  There are certainly security issues.  But for me to learn, to grow, to solve problems, and accomplish goals, I need to connect to people and resources that help me do that.

Creating one profile that extends to all of my networks – to all of my spaces intrigues me. Is this the next step? One place? One profile? Many extensions?

Will all of these eventually be one:

3 thoughts on “David Warlick on the Profile

  • Kendrick Hang

    I think the beginnings of what Warlick is talking about is in FriendFeed. I can create a profile which aggregates my content from various social networks and presents them in one place. There’s also the beginnings of a social network in FriendFeed itself as well — I can see my friends’ friends’ content and filter through the things that I find interesting. An active example is tech blogger Robert Scoble’s friendfeed. Not only is his content (from blogger, flickr, qik, twitter, etc) visible on one page, but also comments and links to profiles of people who find certain bits of his content interesting.

  • Kim Caise

    David, I find this point so interesting. I too agree that educators haven’t found a secure solution to a student network without virtual walls but have made great strides in incorporating current available tools to attempt to create effective networks. I don’t know the solution but I definitely concur with your statement, “But for me to learn, to grow, to solve problems, and accomplish goals, I need to connect to people and resources that help me do that.” The more I learn and grow, the more stifling, or restricting, I find the various technological tools and techniques educators currently use. Personally, I like to take risks and be challenged intellectually and am having a difficult time providing students with real world activities. Any suggestions?

  • Martin

    I’ve just come across another tool that is sort of related – Second Brain. It’s not quite a single profile that you can use on multiple networks like Open ID is for logins but it’s a place where you can aggregate and share your content from across all of your other tools including blogs, bookmarks, flickr, etc.

Comments are closed.